Fall might be the best season to be a pet. It’s finally cool enough for long walks and hikes, cats can reclaim their sun spots without overheating, and the whole month of October comes wrapped in absurdly cute themed gear. Below are our picks for the spookiest, cutest toys and treats for the good boys and ghouls in your life, and because “cute” isn’t the same as “right for your specific animal,” each pick comes with a note on who it actually suits, and where it doesn’t.
A quick note on shopping: these are things our editors and their pets genuinely like. They’re in stock as we publish, but popular seasonal items sell out, so don’t dawdle on the ones you love. If you buy through a link, we may earn a commission.
For the dog who destroys everything
SodaPup Sugar Skull Durable Rubber Chew Toy & Treat Dispenser — $17. This is the workhorse of the list. It’s made in the USA from food-safe, biodegradable natural rubber, it’s dishwasher safe, and it doubles as a slow feeder: pack it with kibble, or stuff and freeze it with dog-safe peanut butter for a treat your dog has to earn. Best for power chewers 30 to 65 pounds who blow through plush toys in an afternoon. Buy on Amazon
ZippyPaws Halloween Dracula RopeTugz — $25. For the extra-scary chewer who wants a tug partner, this smiley little Dracula is built from super-durable rope so it stays in one piece (not a million) through the season. Best for dogs who love to pull; skip it for gentle mouthers who’d rather cuddle a toy than wrestle it.
Jax & Bones Mumford the Mummy Rope Dog Toy — $19. If every toy you buy lasts about as long as a 3,000-year-old mummy, this rope version is your rebuttal, basically indestructible, though your dog will happily spend hours testing that claim. Best for medium-to-large dogs who need something to gnaw.
For the dog who’s really more of a decoration
P.L.A.Y. Howling Haunts Collection — $14. These plush Halloween toys are going to end up scattered across your floor anyway, so they might as well look festive doing it. Best for soft-mouthed dogs and homes that lean into seasonal decor.
The Furry Folks Zombie Nosework Dog Toy — $20. A small-business snuffle-style toy: tuck treats into the zombie’s “hair” and let your dog sniff them out. Best for smart, food-motivated dogs who need mental work more than another squeaker. From a small business.
Lambwolf Limited-Edition Voodoo Toy — $18. A little more scary than spooky, this one has real Wednesday Addams energy. Best for owners who want a design-forward toy; you may want to tuck it away overnight so it doesn’t stare at you.
Dirt + Dog Hair Ouija Board — $20. All the eerie aesthetic of a Ouija board with none of the summoning-the-dead risk, because it’s a pet toy. Best as a photogenic accent for a spooky household.
Fringe Studio Mini Dog Toy Set — $12. A Día de los Muertos-themed mini set and the best value on the list, ideal for pets who aren’t the festive-sweater type but still deserve to join the party. Best for small dogs and multi-toy households.
Bark Puppy Spice Latte Toy — $13. The PSL experience, minus the caffeine that would actually hurt your dog: a plush latte to carry around. Best for plush-loving pups and anyone who finds this as funny as we do.
For the treat-motivated ghoul
Bocce’s Bakery Spooky Season Bundle — $13. The reliably good Bocce’s Bakery gets in on the fun with “Witches Brew” and “Zombie Bites.” Both come separately, but the bundle is the move for maximum spooky value. Best for dogs with no dietary restrictions who love a soft, bakery-style treat.
GivePet Howl-O-Ween Pumpkin & PB Soft Dog Treats — $10. Your dog can’t have a Snickers, but they can have these pumpkin-and-honey softies, and every purchase sends treats to shelter dogs waiting for a home. Best for the buyer who wants their spending to do a little good. Gives back.
The Honest Kitchen Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies — $10. Pumpkin-and-cinnamon treats made with real goat’s milk that disappear about as fast as a real PSL. Best for dogs who tolerate dairy well; go easy if yours is sensitive.
SodaPup Zombies Dog Lick Mat — $16. Fall is peak lick-mat season, with pumpkin, sweet potato, and butternut squash all in their prime as spreadable toppers. This zombie-themed mat turns snack time into a calming ritual. Best for anxious or fast eaters who need to slow down.
Bitch New York Spooky Mini Cupcake Boxed Dog Treats — $21. Dog-safe “cupcakes” for the pet whose birthday energy runs year-round, even if yours skips the universal “phone eats first” rule. Best for a special-occasion splurge.
Bocce’s Bakery Scaredy Snacks Soft & Chewy Treats — $4. The cheapest thing here, and it’s for the cats, a small consolation for felines who have adorable jelly-bean toes but can’t, tragically, have jelly beans. Best for cats who actually accept treats (you know who you are).
For the cat who refuses to acknowledge the holiday
Yustery Acorn Series Catnip Cat Toy — $19. Cats don’t care what month it is, but catnip is forever, and these acorn toys give humans a tasteful excuse to bring fall into the toy basket. Best for catnip-responsive cats and anyone tired of ugly cat toys.
For the pet who wears the costume (or won’t)
Peruvian Knits Day of the Dead Dog Sweater — $48. Spooky season doesn’t end on October 31; Día de Muertos begins November 1, and this calavera sweater lets your pup mark it. It comes in six sizes with a stretchy ribbed panel for broad-chested dogs. Best for cold-weather dogs who tolerate clothing.
Mark and Graham Pumpkin Dog Knit Sweater — $49. A customizable knit that’s a dignified alternative to a full pumpkin costume, for the pup who wants to get through October with their pride intact. Best for dogs who hate elaborate costumes but will accept a sweater.
Arton + Co. Spooky Skater Reversible Tie-On Dog Bandana — $18. If neither you nor your dog is the costume type, this buttery-soft cotton bandana delivers the theme without the itch of a full getup. Best for costume-averse pets and quick festive photos.
The Foggy Dog Pumpkin Velvet Lady Dog Bow — $26. A pumpkin-spice velvet bow for crisp fall walks that repurposes neatly into a Gilmore Girls Halloween look. Best for small dogs and accessory people.
For the practical spooky household
Found My Animal Orange Adjustable Dog Leash — $54. A pumpkin-colored leash with marine-grade rope and hardware, so it pulls double duty as a costume accessory in October and a genuinely safe everyday leash the other eleven months. Best for owners who want seasonal gear that keeps earning its keep.
Wild One Walk Kit in Cocoa — $115 $108. We’ve praised Wild One harnesses before, and this seasonal cocoa colorway is a full walk kit (harness, leash, and more) in a silky neutral that flatters any coat. Best for buyers who want a complete, coordinated setup and don’t mind the splurge.
Kin+kind Organic Healthy Poops Supplement — $25. Fall isn’t only about vibes; it’s about good digestion. Made with pumpkin and flaxseed, this supplement supports firmer stools on those harvest-heavy weeks. Best for dogs with occasionally iffy tummies; check with your vet before adding any supplement.
What’s new this Halloween
Two quick, practical reminders before you fill a cart. First, the treat rules haven’t changed: keep human Halloween candy far out of reach, because chocolate and the sweetener xylitol (now often labeled “birch sugar” or “wood sugar”) are both dangerous to dogs, so stick to the pet-made treats above. Second, on costumes and sweaters, comfort beats cuteness every time, a piece your pet can see, hear, and move freely in is one they’ll actually wear, and anything that makes them freeze or hide isn’t worth the photo. A festive bandana on a happy dog always looks better than an elaborate costume on a miserable one.
Product picks are chosen independently; prices and availability were accurate at publication and may change.
